A two-year fixed mortgage gives you the certainty of a fixed rate for a shorter period, while a five-year fix gives you that certainty for longer. Neither is automatically better - the right choice depends on your circumstances, plans and attitude towards changes in interest rates.
It's one of the most common questions we get asked, and there's more to consider than simply which has the lowest rate today.
What's the difference?
With a fixed-rate mortgage, your mortgage interest rate is fixed for an agreed period.
Choose a two-year fix and you'll generally need to review your mortgage again relatively soon.
Choose five years and you'll know what your interest rate and monthly mortgage payment will be for much longer.
That certainty can be valuable, but you're also committing to the deal for longer.
Why might I choose a two-year fixed mortgage?
A shorter fix can give you more flexibility.
You may want to review your mortgage again relatively soon because you're planning to move, expect your circumstances to change or simply don't want to commit to today's mortgage rates for five years.
The trade-off is that you'll need to consider another mortgage deal sooner.
That could mean another set of product fees and another decision about your mortgage and nobody knows with certainty what mortgage rates will be at that point.
Why might I choose a five-year fixed mortgage?
A five-year fix provides longer-term certainty.
You'll know the interest rate you're paying for five years, which can make household budgeting easier and removes the need to find another deal after only two.
But circumstances change.
If you want to move house, repay a substantial amount or change mortgage during the fixed period, there may be restrictions or early repayment charges. Some mortgages are portable, but the terms and lender's criteria still need to be considered.
What if I think interest rates are going to fall?
It's tempting to base the decision on where we think mortgage rates are heading.
The problem is that none of us knows exactly what rates will be in two, three or five years.
Instead, it's worth considering what you'd be comfortable with if things don't go the way you expect.
Would you value knowing exactly what you'll pay for five years? Or is having the opportunity to review your mortgage sooner more important?
Don't compare the interest rate alone
The mortgage with the lowest headline rate isn't necessarily the cheapest mortgage overall.
Look at product fees, incentives, early repayment charges and the total amount you'll pay over the period you're comparing.
A slightly lower rate accompanied by a substantial product fee, for example, might not represent better value for a smaller mortgage.
Two years or five years?
The question isn't really “Which fixed rate is better?”
It's “Which fixed period is more appropriate for me?”
Consider how long you expect to stay in the property, whether your circumstances could change, how important predictable monthly payments are to you and how comfortable you are with reviewing your mortgage again in two years.
Then compare the actual mortgages available to you.
Not sure how long to fix for?
We'll talk through your plans, look at the mortgages available and explain the differences clearly so you can make a decision that feels right for you.
Clear advice. No crystal ball required. Marvellous.
The information in this guide is for general information only and isn't intended as personal mortgage or financial advice. Mortgage products, rates, lending criteria and individual circumstances vary, so it's important to get advice that's right for you.
Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage.